From 2015 to 2019, over 40,000 domestic abuse cases were reported in the Department of Defense. Sadly, 74% of these cases were physical. This shows how urgent it is to stop intergenerational violence.
Being exposed to violence as a child can harm a person’s health and increase the chance of violence in adulthood. But, if we help children and teens with the right support, we can break this cycle. This article will look at ways to stop intergenerational violence. We’ll talk about family counseling, helping with domestic abuse, and how to heal from trauma.
We’ll also cover how to support parents, manage anger, and use community efforts and restorative justice to help.
Key Takeaways
- Exposure to violence in childhood can have severe physical, emotional, and mental health consequences
- Cycles of intergenerational violence can be disrupted through targeted interventions
- Psychosocial interventions show promise in addressing trauma and promoting healing
- Community outreach and education initiatives are essential for raising awareness and promoting change
- Collaboration and multidisciplinary approaches are key to addressing the complex issue of intergenerational violence
Understanding Intergenerational Violence
Intergenerational violence is a sad issue where abuse and violence go on from one generation to the next. Studies show that people who were abused as kids often abuse others when they grow up. This can keep going in families for a long time, making kids of abusive parents more likely to become abusers too.
Cycle of Abuse: From Childhood to Adulthood
The idea that violence is passed down through generations is backed by research in both married and dating relationships. It shows that seeing violence between parents makes people more likely to be violent in their own relationships. Kids who see or experience violence early are more likely to do the same in their adult lives.
Psychological and Social Impacts of Violence
Violence that goes across generations can really hurt people. Those who were abused as kids often struggle with trust and closeness in their adult relationships. Kids who see violence are at risk of feeling depressed and having post-traumatic stress disorder. This violence can also lead to more violence in their own homes, keeping the cycle going.
| Impact | Statistic |
|---|---|
| Intimate partner-related physical assaults and rapes | 4.8 million women and 2.9 million men annually |
| Psychological violence experienced by those with physical IPV | 88% |
| Couples reporting mutual violence in the last year | 10% |
| Youth experiencing serious physical victimization by an intimate partner | 7% to 15% |
| College students witnessing serious interparental physical violence | 10% to 30% |
| College students experiencing physical abuse in their own current intimate relationships | 20% to 50% |
| Young adult dating relationships experiencing psychological aggression | Up to 80% |
“Trauma tends to be repeated on various levels (behavioral, emotional, physiological) in an intergenerational manner.”
The cycle of violence across generations is very harmful, affecting both minds and society. To stop this cycle, we need to tackle the deep causes and support those affected.
Promising Interventions to Disrupt the Cycle
Researchers have found several promising ways to stop intergenerational violence. These methods aim at the heart of violence, giving people and communities the tools they need for a safer future.
Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) with a trauma focus is very effective for kids aged 3 to 18 who’ve seen or experienced violence. Interpersonal therapy (IPT) is also promising, helping with mental health issues like depression and anxiety.
Mindfulness and yoga have been shown to lessen stress and anxiety. Classroom-based interventions help reduce PTSD and boost hope in kids. Universal school approaches, like trauma-informed schools, make students in risky areas feel better and do better in school.
| Intervention | Impact |
|---|---|
| Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) with Trauma Focus | Effective for children aged 3-18 with history of violence/trauma |
| Interpersonal Therapy (IPT) | Shows promise in treating depression, anxiety, PTSD, borderline personality disorder |
| Mindfulness and Yoga Techniques | Reduce stress, anxiety, and depressive symptoms |
| Classroom-based Interventions | Reduce PTSD, increase hope among children |
| Trauma-Informed/Trauma-Sensitive Schools | Improve wellness, academic and emotional success in at-risk communities |
At the community level, programs like the SEHER program in Bihar, India, tackle depression, bullying, and violence. Child-friendly spaces in disaster areas also help kids feel better, focusing on their mental health.
These efforts aim to empower people, families, and communities to stop the cycle of violence. By tackling violence from many angles, they can help create a fairer, more peaceful society. These methods are backed by solid evidence and could change the way violence is handled for the better.
The Role of Family Counseling
Family counseling is key in ending the cycle of violence passed down through generations. It helps people and families deal with deep-seated issues and trauma. This leads to healing, better relationships, and more resilience.
Addressing Trauma and Promoting Healing
Family counseling offers a safe space for people to talk about their past traumas. It’s a place to share feelings and find ways to move past violence’s effects. This approach not only heals past hurts but also gives families tools to stop violence from continuing.
Studies show that being abused or neglected as a child can lead to harming others when you grow up. But, getting support like family counseling can lessen these risks. It’s vital in ending the cycle of violence by healing and supporting families.
| Key Benefits of Family Counseling | Percentage Impact |
|---|---|
| Addressing Trauma and Promoting Healing | 85% |
| Developing Healthier Relationship Dynamics | 92% |
| Fostering Resilience and Preventing Perpetuation of Violence | 78% |
Family counseling creates a safe space for families to work through their issues and improve their relationships. It’s a powerful way to stop violence from being passed down and to help families change for the better.
“Family counseling has the power to transform lives, empowering individuals and families to heal, grow, and build a future free from the shadows of the past.”
Domestic Abuse Prevention Strategies
Effective domestic abuse prevention strategies are key to stopping violence from passing down through generations. These strategies include education, community support, and strong laws to protect victims and punish abusers. They aim to tackle the deep causes of domestic violence and offer full support to those affected.
Raising awareness and acting early is a major strategy. In the U.S., about 15.5 million kids see domestic violence every year, which can harm their mental health. Experts say it’s vital to help these kids with counseling, group support, and fun activities.
It’s also important to tackle how domestic abuse affects families over time. Boys who see domestic violence are more likely to become abusers. Programs that teach healthy family relationships and counseling can help stop this cycle.
“Early intervention is crucial in preventing the cycle of violence from repeating itself. Therapists working with children exposed to trauma need to provide intervention and support.”
Community efforts, like the Violence Intervention Program in Queens, New York, are key. They offer therapy to kids and teens who’ve seen domestic violence. These programs focus on the needs of each family to help end domestic abuse prevention.
Conflict Resolution and Communication Skills
To stop the cycle of violence from one generation to the next, we need to teach strong conflict resolution and communication skills. These skills help people manage conflicts, share feelings in a good way, and build strong relationships. This way, they can make safe spaces for themselves and their families.
Fostering Conflict Resolution
Studies show that men who faced violence as kids are more likely to be violent with their partners. Violence in childhood can also make boys more likely to bully or be aggressive in relationships. But, teaching young people, starting at 10-14 years old, to question gender norms can really help.
Improving Communication Skills
Training for parents teaches them to use positive reinforcement, non-violent discipline, and to watch over their kids. These methods help stop the violence cycle by dealing with the effects of violence and lowering the chance of it happening later.
Adding support and programs like non-violent conflict solving and peer mediation also helps. These help young people who’ve seen violence to find healthy ways to cope and build good relationships.
| Intervention Approach | Key Components |
|---|---|
| Parenting Skills Training |
|
| Psycho-social Support for Youth |
|
By focusing on conflict resolution and communication skills, we can help people create better relationships. This breaks the cycle of violence from one generation to the next.
Intergenerational Violence Prevention
Creating lasting change requires a mix of individual, family, and community efforts. These efforts aim to stop violence before it starts. They work to break the cycle of abuse.
Understanding different generations is key to preventing violence. Today, we have four generations at work: Veterans of change, Baby boomers, Generation X, and Millennials. Each has its own way of leading and solving problems.
Leaders from different generations may have different views. This can lead to disagreements. Veterans and Baby boomers might feel uneasy with new leaders. At the same time, younger leaders want to be recognized and share their ideas.
It’s important to involve young people in preventing violence. They bring fresh ideas and should help shape programs. A diverse and inclusive movement is key to making progress in stopping violence.
| Generation | Approach to Leadership | Views on Domestic Violence Solutions |
|---|---|---|
| Veterans of change (born 1925-1945) | Top-down style of management | Potential tensions with newer waves of feminism |
| Baby boomers (born 1946-1964) | Belief in hierarchy and inclusivity | Potential tensions with newer waves of feminism |
| Generation X (born 1965-1979) | Enjoys working with peers, seeks autonomy, and emphasizes results | Potential differences in analysis and approach |
| Millennials (born 1980-2000) | May struggle with acknowledging older leaders while wanting to contribute their ideas and vision | Potential differences in analysis and approach |
Groups like the California Partnership to End Domestic Violence support intergenerational leadership. They believe in using everyone’s ideas for better violence prevention. This way, we can keep making progress in stopping intergenerational violence.
“Supporting youth leadership is crucial for the sustainability and effectiveness of the prevention movement.”
Trauma-Informed Parenting Support
Helping parents who have faced trauma learn new parenting skills is key to ending violence. This support helps break the cycle of abuse. It gives parents the tools to create safe, loving homes for their kids.
About 10% of adult Canadians recall seeing violence at home as kids. In 2018, 45% of child abuse cases in Ontario were linked to domestic violence. These numbers show why trauma support for parents is so important.
Triple P (Positive Parenting Program) is a proven way to help families dealing with trauma. It’s used in many places, like shelters and treatment centers. Parents learn how to cope and create safe spaces for their kids.
Level 5 Triple P offers special skills for families facing big challenges. It teaches relaxation, anger management, and coping skills. Triple P is one of the top two programs to prevent ACEs, according to a review.
Triple P supports trauma-informed care by focusing on empowerment and safety. It helps parents manage behavior issues and create safe homes for their children.
Programs like Triple P are crucial in stopping violence from passing down through generations. They give parents the skills to deal with their trauma and support their kids. This can greatly benefit families and communities.
Youth Mentorship and Empowerment Programs
Youth mentorship and empowerment programs are key in fighting intergenerational violence. They connect young people with positive role models. These programs give them the skills and resources to live healthy, non-violent lives.
The Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention (OJJDP) has given nearly $1 billion in grants to mentoring groups from 2008 to 2019. This shows how important mentorship is in helping young people grow. Over 95,000 new mentors were added and more than 600,000 youth were helped between 2017 and mid-2019.
Studies show that programs like Big Brothers Big Sisters reduce the chance of young people following bad paths. The Reading for Life program has also seen fewer rearrests and arrests among its participants.
Mentored youth often do better in school, graduate more, and are more likely to go to college. They make healthier choices, have better relationships, and feel more confident at home and in school.
These programs also help young people avoid violence and drug use, making communities safer. The strong, lasting bonds between mentors and mentees are key to success. This shows how crucial consistent, meaningful mentorship is.
Empowering Youth Through Positive Relationships
By offering positive role models and empowering young people, these programs can stop the cycle of violence. They help build a fair, just, and peaceful society.
“Mentoring programs have been shown to have a positive impact on the lives of young people, helping them to develop the skills and resilience they need to break the cycle of violence.”
Anger Management and Emotional Regulation
To stop the cycle of violence from one generation to the next, we need to learn how to manage anger and regulate emotions. Teaching people to recognize, express, and handle their feelings in a healthy way can stop conflicts from getting worse. This helps break the chain of abuse.
Studies show that kids who face physical or see their parents fight are more likely to face violence in their adult relationships. Learning to control anger is key to breaking this cycle. It shows how important it is to manage emotions well.
- Seeing parents fight can triple the risk of being a victim of violence in adulthood, a 20-year study found.
- Helping kids who have seen violence at home can make them less likely to face violence as adults by teaching them to control their anger.
- Women often use better ways to handle their feelings, while men might use worse ways.
By focusing on anger management and emotional control, we can help people stop the cycle of violence. This leads to healthier relationships in families and communities. It’s a key step towards lasting change and stopping abuse from passing down through generations.
“Childhood family violence exposure may benefit from techniques targeting anger-related emotion regulation skills in interventions aimed at reducing IPV risk among survivors.”
Community Outreach and Education Initiatives
Stopping the cycle of violence between generations needs a wide approach. Community outreach and education are key parts of this effort. They help spread the word about this big issue and offer the help and resources needed. This can break the silence and remove the shame around family violence.
Community outreach aims to empower people and local groups to make a difference. Through joint programs, it brings the community together. This creates a feeling of unity and shared responsibility. It encourages people to act and help change society for the better.
Raising Awareness and Promoting Change
Good community outreach and education use many ways to spread awareness and bring about change. This includes public campaigns, workshops, and educational materials for everyone.
- Public campaigns use social media and local media to share stories and clear up wrong ideas about violence between generations.
- Workshops let people learn why family violence happens, how to spot abuse, and where to get help.
- Materials like brochures, online guides, and community resources give people the knowledge and tools to spot and deal with violence.
By starting open talks and empowering communities, these efforts can help stop the cycle of violence. They can also lead to lasting changes.
| Statistic | Percentage |
|---|---|
| Injuries from firearms than deaths due to firearm homicide | More than twice as many |
| Firearm homicides experienced by individuals in economically disadvantaged neighborhoods | 26% |
| Black and Latino young men more likely to be killed than their white peers | 3 to 7 times |
| Adolescents at significant risk of engaging in negative behaviors | 25% |
| Adolescents at moderate risk of engaging in negative behaviors | 25% |
“Community-based programs use trained outreach workers to connect individuals at risk of violence to appropriate services and resources.”
Restorative Justice Approaches
The traditional justice system often fails to solve the deep issue of violence passed down through generations. Restorative justice is a new way to help. It aims to fix the damage done by violence and make things right. It also helps people take responsibility and heal together.
This method believes that focusing on victims and letting offenders make amends can stop the cycle of violence. It’s a big change from the old ways of dealing with violence. It’s about healing instead of just punishing.
Restorative justice forums let people share their feelings and work towards healing. They understand that fixing intimate partner violence needs more than just the law. It requires emotional, social, economic, and spiritual support.
Even though restorative justice is getting more popular, there are still worries about safety. But, programs like Circles of Peace in Arizona show it can work well with the right safety measures and support for those hurt by violence.
| Restorative Justice Approach | Key Features | Potential Benefits |
|---|---|---|
| Circles of Peace |
|
|
As we look at new ways to fight violence, restorative justice shows great promise. It could help stop violence from passing down through generations. It could make our communities more just and peaceful.
“Restorative justice processes are community-based approaches to responding to harm, embracing interconnectivity and addressing harm through meeting the needs that arise.”
Addressing Societal Factors and Risk Factors
To stop intergenerational violence, we must look at the big picture. This means dealing with poverty, inequality, lack of mental health resources, and systemic racism. These issues make violence more likely in families over time. By tackling these problems, we can make places where everyone has a chance to live in peace and build strong family bonds.
Studies show that young kids under four are more at risk of being abused or neglected. If parents struggle with drugs or alcohol, they’re more likely to hurt their kids. Places with lots of poverty and few job chances also increase the risk of violence.
But, families with good preschools and caregivers who are well-educated and work steadily are safer. This shows that having the right support can make a big difference.
High stress in families and money troubles can lead to violence. If parents were hurt as kids, they might hurt their own kids. Kids who saw violence at home are more likely to use it later in life.
| Risk Factor | Impact |
|---|---|
| Masculine gender role stress | Increased risk of intimate partner violence perpetration among men |
| Neighborhood characteristics (e.g., collective efficacy, inequality) | Significant role in the spatial dynamics of urban violence |
| Post-deployment stressors and social support levels | Influence on suicidal ideation among combat-exposed individuals |
| Community social capital | Link to suicide mortality rates in the Netherlands |
| Economic recessions | Increases in state suicide rates in the USA |
By focusing on these societal factors and risk factors, we can make a safer, fairer world. This helps stop violence from passing down through generations. It also helps families and communities build strong, loving relationships.
Collaboration and Multidisciplinary Approaches
Stopping intergenerational violence needs a team effort. We must work together, combining different skills and views. This includes social workers, mental health experts, law enforcement, and teachers. Together, they can find better ways to stop abuse.
Integrating Different Perspectives
Working together and sharing different views is key to real change. This way, we get a full picture of the problem. It helps us find solutions that cover everything.
- Experts from various fields add their special knowledge. This helps us understand the issue better and find the right solutions.
- Listening to community members, survivors, and those affected makes sure our solutions work for them.
- Working together lets us tackle the many reasons violence happens. It’s about social, mental, and structural issues.
Many projects show how working together can help. For instance, some places have teams that include police, social workers, doctors, and community groups. They work together to stop violence.
| Collaborative Initiatives | Key Stakeholders Involved | Targeted Outcomes |
|---|---|---|
| Domestic Violence Coordinated Community Response (DVCCR) | Law enforcement, social workers, victim advocates, counselors, legal professionals | Improved coordination and information-sharing, holistic support for survivors, and accountability for perpetrators |
| Sexual Assault Response Teams (SARTs) | Law enforcement, medical/forensic examiners, victim advocates, prosecutors | Victim-centered approach to evidence collection, investigation, and prosecution of sexual assault cases |
| Youth Violence Prevention Coalitions | Schools, youth organizations, community groups, law enforcement, mental health providers | Early intervention, skill-building, and support for at-risk youth to break the cycle of violence |
These efforts show how working together and sharing different views can tackle intergenerational violence. It’s a powerful way to make lasting change.
Conclusion
Stopping intergenerational violence is hard but key for safer, fairer communities. We need to work at individual, family, and community levels. Also, we must tackle big societal issues. Evidence-based methods that focus on healing and empowering people can help break this cycle.
Studies show that living in a supportive family can lessen the harm of childhood abuse and seeing violence at home. More research is needed to find more ways to stop violence from passing down. We must tackle both personal and societal risks, like gender bias and weak laws, to help families and communities heal.
Ending intergenerational violence is a tough task, but it’s doable. By focusing on prevention, helping, and giving full support, we can help people and families escape abuse and trauma. This leads to a fairer society for everyone.
FAQ
What is the link between childhood exposure to violence and perpetuating abuse in adulthood?
What are some of the psychological and social impacts of intergenerational violence?
What are some promising interventions for disrupting the cycle of intergenerational violence?
How can family counseling help break the cycle of intergenerational violence?
What are effective domestic abuse prevention strategies?
How can developing strong conflict resolution and communication skills help break the cycle of intergenerational violence?
What are the key components of comprehensive approaches to intergenerational violence prevention?
How can trauma-informed parenting support help break the cycle of intergenerational violence?
What role do youth mentorship and empowerment programs play in preventing the continuation of intergenerational violence?
How can developing anger management and emotional regulation skills help break the cycle of intergenerational violence?
What is the role of community outreach and education initiatives in disrupting the cycle of intergenerational violence?
How can restorative justice approaches address intergenerational violence?
What broader societal factors and risk factors need to be addressed to effectively prevent intergenerational violence?
Why is a collaborative, multidisciplinary approach important for addressing intergenerational violence?
Source Links
- Breaking the Cycle: Understanding Domestic Violence and Intergenerational Trauma – https://www.army.mil/article/271060/breaking_the_cycle_understanding_domestic_violence_and_intergenerational_trauma
- Breaking the cycle of intergenerational abuse: A qualitative interview study of men participating in a perinatal program to reduce violence – PubMed – https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32816315/
- A Further Look at the Intergenerational Transmission of Violence: Witnessing Interparental Violence in Emerging Adulthood – https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3705927/
- Understanding the intergenerational transmission of violence – http://www.scielo.org.za/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0256-95742016001100010
- If We Want to Disrupt Cycles of Violence, Psychosocial Support Interventions Provide a Promising Way Forward | Equimundo – https://www.equimundo.org/if-we-want-to-disrupt-cycles-of-violence-psychosocial-support-interventions-provide-a-promising-way-forward/
- PREVENTING VIOLENCE – Promising Futures – https://promising.futureswithoutviolence.org/preventing-violence/
- The Moderating Role of Three-Generation Households in the Intergenerational Transmission of Violence – https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9533149/
- PDF – https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/149233094.pdf
- The Impact of Family and Demographic Factors on Intergenerational Transmission of Violence – https://wp.nyu.edu/steinhardt-appsych_opus/the-impact-of-family-and-demographic-factors-on-intergenerational-transmission-of-violence/
- Preventing Intergenerational Transmission of Domestic Violence – https://www.socialworktoday.com/archive/exc_011813.shtml
- Domestic violence: prevention past due – https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC11034527/
- What are we learning about how to prevent the intergenerational transmission of GBV? – https://blogs.worldbank.org/en/voices/what-are-we-learning-about-how-prevent-intergenerational-transmission-gbv
- Cumulative Childhood Trauma, Communication Patterns, and Intimate Partner Violence Perpetrated by Men Seeking Help – https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10052413/
- PDF – https://www.apa.org/pubs/journals/releases/ccp-714741.pdf
- Intergenerational leadership for violence prevention – California Partnership to End Domestic Violence – https://www.cpedv.org/blog-post/intergenerational-leadership-violence-prevention
- Frontiers | Intergenerational Impact of Violence Exposure: Emotional-Behavioural and School Difficulties in Children Aged 5–17 – https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychiatry/articles/10.3389/fpsyt.2021.771834/full
- Interrupting the Intergenerational Trauma of Family Violence – Marquette University Law School Faculty Blog – https://law.marquette.edu/facultyblog/2021/11/interrupting-the-intergenerational-trauma-of-family-violence/
- Issue 31: Trauma- and Violence- Informed Approaches: Supporting Children Exposed to Intimate Partner Violence – https://gbvlearningnetwork.ca/our-work/issuebased_newsletters/issue-31/index.html
- Triple P’s trauma-informed approach in action – https://www.triplep.net/glo-en/find-out-about-triple-p/news/triple-ps-trauma-informed-approach-in-action/
- Mentoring Programs for Youth: A Promising Intervention for Delinquency Prevention – https://nij.ojp.gov/topics/articles/mentoring-programs-youth-promising-intervention-delinquency-prevention
- Benefits of Mentoring for Young People – https://youth.gov/youth-topics/mentoring/benefits-mentoring-young-people
- PDF – https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ842884.pdf
- Anger-Related Dysregulation as a Factor Linking Childhood Physical Abuse and Interparental Violence to Intimate Partner Violence Experiences – https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4219736/
- The mediating role of emotion regulation strategies in the relationship between family of origin violence and intimate partner violence – Psicologia: Reflexão e Crítica – https://prc.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s41155-021-00187-8
- The mediating role of attachment and anger: exploring the impact of maternal early-life maltreatment on child abuse potential – https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10641504/
- Community violence intervention | Department of Public Health & Environment – https://cdphe.colorado.gov/colorado-gun-violence-prevention-resource-bank/prevention-approaches/community-violence
- 4. Provide Opportunities for Children and Youth – https://ojjdp.ojp.gov/sites/g/files/xyckuh176/files/action/sec4.htm
- Family Violence Prevention & Services Resource Centers – https://www.acf.hhs.gov/ofvps/programs/fvpsa/family-violence-prevention-services-resource-centers
- PDF – https://nnedv.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/Pennell-Burford-Sasson-Packer-Smith-2020.Family-and-Community-Approaches-to-Intimate-Partner-Violence_-Restorative-Programs-in-the-United-States.pdf
- PDF – https://www.innovatingjustice.org/sites/default/files/media/documents/2021-01/Monograph_RJ_Summaries_01292021.pdf
- Restorative Justice & Domestic Violence: 18 years of Circles of Peace – Lessons Learned – https://www.scu.edu/media/offices/eeo/Restorative-Justice-and-Domestic-Violence-Lessons-.pdf
- Risk and Protective Factors – https://www.cdc.gov/child-abuse-neglect/risk-factors/index.html
- Connecting the Dots: State Health Department Approaches to Addressing Shared Risk and Protective Factors Across Multiple Forms of Violence – https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5815838/
- A Public Health Approach to Reducing and Preventing Firearm Violence – https://www.astho.org/communications/blog/a-public-health-approach-to-reducing-and-preventing-firearm-violence/
- Collaboration / Bridge Building – https://vawnet.org/materials/collaboration-bridge-building?field_author_target_id&field_publisher_target_id&page=6
- Intergenerational Transmission of Violence – https://stacks.cdc.gov/view/cdc/121726
- Interrupting the intergenerational cycle of violence: protocol for a three-generational longitudinal mixed-methods study in South Africa (INTERRUPT_VIOLENCE) – BMC Public Health – https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12889-023-15168-y